2024:
1st Team All-American
Women's Track & Field
Aja Jackson
2nd Team All-American
Women's Track & Field
Aja Jackson
Honorable Mention All-American
Men's Track & Field
Thomas Eccleston
2023:
1st Team All-American
Women's Track & Field
Aja Jackson
2nd Team All-American
Women's Cross Country
Aja Jackson
Women's Track & Field
Megan Carden
Honorable Mention All-American
Men's Track & Field
Conner Smith
Aden Hollenbeck
Women's Track & Field
Aja Jackson
Mariella Michitti
Melissa Carden
Megan Carden
2022:
1st Team All-American
Men's Cross Country
Conner Smith
Women's Cross Country
Aja Jackson
Women's Soccer
Arianna Michitti
Women's Track & Field
Megan Carden
2nd Team All-American
Men's Cross Country
Jakob Getchell
Women's Soccer
Dana Stepp
Men's Track & Field
Conner Smith
Honorable Mention All American
Women's Track & Field
Melissa Carden
2021:
1st Team All-American
Women's Soccer
Arianna Michitti
2nd Team All-American
Men's Cross Country
Lucas Baker
2nd Team All-American
Volleyball
Mackenzie Struble
Honorable Mention All-American
Men's Cross Country
Conner Smith
Honorable Mention All-American
Volleyball
Savannah Davis
2019:
2nd Team All-Americans
Volleyball
Brianna Kosinski
2018:
2nd Team Singles All-Americans
Women's Tennis
Brianna Harmon
2016:
2nd Team All-Americans
Ice Hockey
Austin Bradish
1st Team All-Americans
Women's Soccer
Kaelyn Michitti
2nd Team All-Americans
Women's Soccer
Emily Gibson
2015:
All-American Team
Ice Hockey
Cory Della Stua
Andrew Meeker
1st Team All-Americans
Women's Soccer
Rosemary Zelenyak
2nd Team All-Americans
Women's Soccer
Emily Caslin
2014:
1st Team All-Americans
Ice Hockey
Cory Della Stua
2013:
1st Team All-Americans
Women's Soccer
Danielle Tabeek
2012:
2nd Team All-Americans
Women's Soccer
Emily Icenogle
2011:
All-American Team:
Women's Lacrosse
Kasey Kuzma
2010:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Ice Hockey
Cameron Gunn
2009:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Brenna Campbell
2008:
All-American Team:
Golf
Tyler Jenson
1st Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Sarah Furminger
Tori Matt
2nd Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Katie Schild
2007:
All-American Team:
Women's Soccer
Callista Karl
Erika Puffer
1st Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Emily Dixon
1st Team All-Americans:
Golf
Tom Hacket
2nd Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Emily Cirillo
2006:
All-American Team:
Women's Soccer
Amber Pratt
1st Team All-Americans:
Softball
Michelle Forsburg
Megan Phillips
2nd Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Rebecca Waldo
2005:
All-American Team:
Softball
Michelle Forsburg
Theresa Newberry
1st Team All-Americans:
Woman's Basketball
Amy Dodd
2004:
All-American Team:
Women's Soccer
Melissa Tabeek
1st Team All-Americans:
Woman's Basketball
Marcy Lilley
1st Team All-Americans:
Woman's Soccer
Melissa Tabeek
2003:
All-American Team:
Softball
Amy Martino
Kim Wood
1st Team All-Americans:
Men's Soccer
Zack Manning
2nd Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Paige Rosenbacker
2nd Team All-Americans:
Men's Soccer
Nicholas Bunnell
2002:
All-American Team:
Softball
Melinda Springsteen
3rd Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Julie Sedlak
2001:
All-American Team:
Softball
Melinda Springsteen
2nd Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Andrea McAffe
2000:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Men's Soccer
Reilly Buckley
Jamile Green
Bryan Homsher
2nd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Michael Smith
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Amy Skryzpeck
1999:
All-American Team:
Softball
Samantha Fancher
1st Team All-Americans:
Women's Soccer
Corinne Bowman
3rd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Jim Evans
1998:
All-American Team:
Softball
Ilene Whitney
2nd Team All-Americans:
Baseball
Marc Danko
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Jim Evans
1997:
All-American Team:
Women's Soccer
Melissa Korosec
1st Team All-Americans:
Women's Cross Country
Alecia Brown
1995:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Men's Cross Country
Mike Kent
1994:
3rd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Charles Georgia
1991:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Men's Soccer
Wendol Williams
1986:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Ice Hockey
Mark Blaha
1985:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Ice Hockey
Chris Luchuk
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Baseball
Mike DiRienzo
1984:
1st Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
David Potts
2nd Team All-Americans:
Volleyball
Julie Beauman
1983:
1st Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
David Potts
1981:
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Baseball
Joe Gebo
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Ron Thorpe
1980:
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Ben Gardenhire
1979:
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Soccer
Dennis Peckham
1978:
3rd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Curtis Miller
1976:
3rd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Larry Lane
1975:
3rd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Curtis Miller
1974:
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Lee Strubeck
1973:
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Greg Baldwin
1971:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Gerry Newby
1969:
1st Team All-Americans:
Men's Soccer
Feyyaz Baskent
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Allen Crews
1968:
1st Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Frank Streety
2nd Team All-Americans:
Men's Soccer
Barry Decouto
1967:
3rd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Donald Beary
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Frank Streety
1965:
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Phil Meagley
1964:
1st Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Charles Georgia
1963:
1st Team All-Americans:
Men's Soccer
Bill Skojec
3rd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
John Emza
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Baseball
Ken Moses
1962:
1st Team All-Americans:
Men's Soccer
Roger DuBois
3rd Team All-Americans:
Baseball
Wendall Terry
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Baseball
Donald Heller
1961:
1st Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Bob Williams
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Donald Heller
1960:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Dick Kenny
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Baseball
Gary Prichard
Wendall Terry
1958:
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Gene Battaglini
1957:
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Baseball
Dick Alapeck
Honorable Mention All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Dick Alapeck
1955:
2nd Team All-Americans:
Men's Basketball
Bernie Benson
